senckađ
Group745
Group745
Group745
Group745
Group745
Group745
Thought Leaders in association withPartners in Crime
Group745

The Death of the Holding Company

19/01/2023
Advertising Agency
Denver, USA
262
Share
Faraz Maqsood Hamidi, chief creative officer of The D’Hamidi Partnership explains how holding companies are struggling to reinvent themselves

Forgive the sensationally morbid headline, but now that you're here, it might be worth your time to consider why the behemoth holding companies of yore that ruled the roost up till now may in fact have gone way past their best-by date.

This shouldn't surprise us. In the age of goliath networks, concentrated creative and media services in the analogue universe successfully helped clients looking for scope, scale and the single-window to the outside world. But in the age of the digital multiverse, commerce is increasingly being built through creativity, collaboration and connectivity. And considering that everyone is their own publisher and broadcaster in the sharing economy, there has never been a better time to celebrate co-creation, independence and individuality - for the benefit of the clients we serve.

In this context, holding companies are struggling to reinvent themselves. They're facing their own 'Kodak Moment,' so to speak. It's not their fault. Apart from a very limited number of large, global advertisers who see holding companies as providers of global capabilities and scale, most clients today are looking for collaborative, agile teams that are swift and responsive to their needs in a tech-enabled, digitally-centric, remote-controlled world. Asking holding companies to deliver this mix of speed and specialist capabilities is asking them to dismantle the bureaucratic and often rigid hierarchies that define them. In any such organization, the culture places emphasis on internal competition over generous collaboration.

Moreover, holding companies housing the integrated agency model are often shiny on the outside, but leave a lot to be desired on the inside. The only people who will deny this are the ones running these bureaucracies. Just ask the executive-vice-assistant-to-the-intern who answered your last phone call. While you're at it, a better question to ask is whether these holding companies have the instinct and appetite to direct the thrust of their ambitions (read: money) to create the kind of ecosystem that is relevant and resonates with today's markets? Can they shed the deadwood and fill their ranks with a tighter, nimbler and smarter group of change-makers who came into the creative space looking to do just that in that first place?

To be fair, every organisation conforms to its purpose. Yet, they must continually adapt with time to avoid risking petrification. If holding companies are to increase their relevance, they must do something so immensely valued in our industry in ways that will ultimately mute their critics. That 'something' is fostering creative talent. If holding companies become a pantheon of the creative arts that can attract, groom, and retain the world's most sterling creative talent (instead of seeing them open their own shops), their extraordinary output - not to mention, inspiration for the industry - will keep them relevant and invaluable for the next generation of creative flag-bearers. This is foreseeable, because they have the muscle to flex change.

But it might never happen. A brutal untangling of agency services is underway. Agencies used to be citadels of ideas, cultivating insanity in bite-sized pieces for brave clients. But they're falling prey to digital fodder: one-man hacks who produce social tiles that are grouted with mediocrity. Moreover, in-house teams have brought standards even lower for fear of unrealistic deadlines designed for speed-to-market, under the glare of unimaginative supervisors. Add to this the search for cheaper suppliers and vendors who are assigned to different parts of the process making the process itself - and its results - a patchwork of signed-off compromises. And let's not even talk about getting hammered by tech giants, consultancies, and the chairman's wife.

Maybe the role of the holding company is no longer to 'hold' the network together, but to unleash its potential far and wide. Giving permission to its agents to mix and migrate, cross-pollinate and cultivate new avenues of creative discovery. The kind of stuff that leads to real growth for clients. Holding companies are great at scaling and building shareholder value. But they're not great at putting creativity before efficiency. For that to happen, they need to move away from the soft, edible centre of their world to the sharp edges of innovation and creativity. That happens among the outliers, among the independents. Unless the holding companies evolve into a network that is owned by the agencies (and not the other way around), it's likely that they may have finally limped into their deadline.


Article by Faraz Maqsood Hamidi, chief creative officer of independent agency The D’Hamidi Partnership in Pakistan. First published in Aurora, a DAWN Group Publication.

Credits
Work from Worldwide Partners
The Discovery of a Lifetime
Atlantis, Paradise Island
20/12/2023
9
0
Here Anthem
VISIT FLORIDA
02/11/2023
192
0
The Trucket List
RealTruck
10/11/2022
29
0
ALL THEIR WORK