Get your own Little Black Book.

Build your own personal news stream. Discover the latest work created that interests you, share your favourite stories and follow your favourite people and companies

Already have an account?

Opinion and Insight

Debenhams is the Winner in the Battle of the Christmas Ads

lbbonline.com, 11 months, 1 week ago

Analysis of 15,000 tweets reviewed public sentiment about various brands' festive offerings

Debenhams is the Winner in the Battle of the Christmas Ads

Amid much anticipation and expectation, the Christmas TV commercials have aired. Industry comment and opinion about which one is best is rife, but how do those whose opinion really matters feel?

Conran Design Group has partnered with Adoreboard to find out how TV viewers feel about this year’s selection of Christmas ads, from retailers and supermarkets alike.
 
They analysed 15,000 tweets from 2–14 November, reviewing what people are saying about this year’s Christmas ads: which one struck a cord and which one is a turkey!
 
JWT's Debenhams ad, ‘You shall’, is the clear winner this year when it comes to emotional engagement, with a score of 66 on a scale of -100 to 100. Of the 15,000 tweets analysed, people took to social media to discuss the ‘joy’ and ‘trust’ they felt about this year’s ad from the retailer. Viewers like the fairy tale theme and they feel that the magic of Christmas has been captured ("I think this has to be the best Christmas ad so far #YouShall. Who doesn't love a good romance?")
 
Marks & Spencer ranks second with ‘Paddington Bear and the Christmas visitor’. The ad has connected with viewers on an emotional level, who expressed joy in their posts at seeing much loved character Paddington Bear. (@paddingtonbear @marksandspencer I love the ad! It's magical! And so are you, Paddington. #lovethebear")

Asda’s ad, ‘Imaginarium’ ranks in third place.

Tesco and Amazon performed the worst in the review ranking 15 and 16 respectively. With a score of just 31, Tesco’s ad revealed high levels of ‘sadness’ and ‘anger’.  The grocer’s attempt at inclusivity has received a backlash on Twitter with people voicing strong opinions about the brand’s motives. ("Loving how outraged some people are by the Tesco Christmas ad featuring gay and Muslim families. What a shock to people's small minds")
 
Amazon’s ad scored the lowest at -5 and reveals high levels of ‘anger’ from parents complaining that the ad implies Santa isn’t real and therefore spoils Christmas for their children. ("@amazon why are you spoiling kids Christmas with your stupid TV ad? Christmas presents come from Santa surely!")

Potentially the most surprising reveal is that the perennial favourite, John Lewis, shares sixth place with other retailers. While 20% of all tweets are about the brand, when it comes to emotionally engaging viewers this year, the brand hasn’t achieved former success.

Retailer

TV ad

Adorescore

Rank

Debenhams

‘Cinderella’

66

1

Marks & Spencer

‘Paddington Bear and the Christmas Visitor’

62

2

Asda

‘The Imaginarium’

59

3

Very.co.uk

‘Anna and Ulfie’

57

4

Aldi

‘Kevin the Carrot’

57

4

Boots

‘Sister love’

55

6

John Lewis

‘Moz the Monster’

55

6

House of Fraser

‘Sister relationships’

55

6

Morrisons

‘Sibling love and support’

55

6

Waitrose

‘Snowed in at Christmas’

55

6

Vodafone

Martin Freeman - "A Christmas Love Story"

53

11

Lidl

‘Homecoming’ (reused 2016) and Short food ads

51

12

Sainsbury’s

‘Singalong’

49

13

Argos

‘Ready for takeoff’

44

14

Tesco

‘Family Christmas’

31

15

Amazon

‘Dad Hiding presents’

-5

16



The full table:

Retailer

TV ad

Hashtag

Adorescore

Emotions

Rank

 

 

 

 

Joy

Trust

Anger

Sadness

 

Debenhams

‘Cinderella’

 

66

56

50

10

6

1

Marks & Spencer

‘Paddington Bear and the Christmas Visitor’

#LoveTheBear

62

53

48

9

7

2

Asda

‘The Imaginarium’

 

59

53

42

6

5

3

Very.co.uk

‘Anna and Ulfie’

 

57

51

42

12

3

3

Aldi

‘Kevin the Carrot’

#KevinAndKatie

57

48

43

11

6

5

Boots

‘Sister love’

#ShowThemYouKnowThem

55

48

39

6

6

6

John Lewis

‘Moz the Monster’

#MozTheMonster

55

52

39

6

11

6

House of Fraser

‘Sister relationships’

#BringMerryBack

55

47

38

9

6

6

Morrisons

‘Sibling love and support’

 

55

54

37

12

9

9

Waitrose

‘Snowed in at Christmas’

#ChristmasTogether

55

46

37

7

7

10

Vodafone

Martin Freeman - "A Christmas Love Story"

 

53

45

43

9

12

11

Lidl

‘Homecoming’ (reused 2016) and Short food ads

 

51

43

36

9

11

11

Sainsbury’s

‘Singalong’

#EveryBitOfChristmas

49

44

36

11

11

13

Argos

‘Ready for take-off’

#ReadyForTakeOff

44

30

29

13

17

14

Tesco

‘Family Christmas’

#EveryonesWelcome

31

30

29

13

17

15

Amazon

‘Dad Hiding presents’

 

-5

26

22

19

16

16


Sign up to our newsletters and stay up to date with the best work and breaking ad news from around the world.